PORTFOLIO VERSION: The Green Book & Orientalism

Orientalism is the way that we- as westerners view and stereotype the people and cultures which make up the eastern world. Though the general idea of orientalism stems from a group of people placing their own ideas on labels on another group simply because they are different; this concept can be represented in many different situations. The film Green Book confronts us with the segregation between whites and blacks in the southern U.S during the early 20th century.

Orientalism is prevalent from the moment we are introduced to Dr. Don. His New York City apartment is filled with “exotic” (to us westerners) pieces: African sculptures, elephant tusks, glassware. Dr. Don is clearly in a financial position to be able to afford these luxury goods, but it still dramatized eastern culture- which I’m sure was very intentional. 

Dr. Don Shirley in his New York City apartment

Edward Said, in his book Orientalism describes that “The relationship between Occident and Orient is a relationship of power, of domination.” The treatment of Dr. Don throughout the film attests to this claim. Time after time, whites place labels on Dr. Don before making an effort to know him. Both Tony and the hosts of a dinner party he performed at just assumed that since he was black, Dr. Don must love fried chicken. This might seem insignificant in magnitude compared to some other possible stereotypes, but is a straightforward representation of how whites are quick to place labels in the film. There also were many moments of sheer segregation and overpower: a white shop owner refusing to let Dr. Don try on a suit, a dinner party host refusing to let him use the restroom. In their own way, these show the dominance many westerners feel they are entitled to have over easterners 

One of the most compelling facets of The Green Book to me was that despite the typical stereotypes and segregations shown, there was still a sense of role reversal. In a film set during this time of American history, I think most would be quick to assume that the black man would be the one chauffeuring the intelligent rich white man throughout the country. In fact, it was the other way around. Dr. Don was the wealthy, well-spoken, well-dressed man, helping Tony write eloquent letters to his family, critiquing his smoking and badgering him to not swear. It was a different perspective than the one usually seen in movies from this time- and while there were difficult moments to see- it was a refreshing shift. My predisposition to see things from an orientalist perspective never would have let me assume Dr. Don would be the one to save him and Tony from jail. Despite Dr. Don’s humiliation about the situation, it was a powerful moment.

While the whites in this film wanted the power and thought they had the power, Dr. Don truly held the power. The Green Book challenges our predisposed orientalist views, giving us a heavy reminder of the difficult past our country has faced.  

Published by gretaghei

I'm Greta, gg to my friends, greta goose to my family and baby g to my dad. I have lived in Milwaukee, Wisconsin my whole life, and no matter where I am, or end up, I will always be proud to call Wisconsin home. My summers spent on Lake Michigan were met with fun adventures with my family throughout other seasons. I love sharing stories of travel and hearing about the places other people have seen. During our travels, my family enjoys wandering (alot), eating at the best restaurants, and making friends with sommeliers. None of us enjoy chaos and we tend to skip most tourist activities and iconic sights. I'm the youngest child of two older siblings who both are out of college and living in New York City, making us a bicoastal family (with our parents holding the fort down in the midwest). I love being outside, can't sit still for long periods of time, and am always looking for ways to expand my view of the world.

Leave a comment

Design a site like this with WordPress.com
Get started